The Simpsons: Controversy Over Same-sex Matrimony

In an episode of The Simpsons that aired across the U.S. today, Springfield legalises same-sex marriage and two men are joined in matrimony. A number of Americans are outraged at this, and in the culture war, there is fiery debate over the possible immoral implications of the producers’ actions and the definition of marriage.

Do I believe in same-sex marriage? I believe that we live in an ever-evolving and -changing world; we do not live in the 19th century, regardless of some people’s small-minded mentality. I believe that there is a considerable amount of homosexual people in the world and a subsequent high demand for their equal rights; it makes sense to allow these people the opportunity to them. Certain governments are depriving homosexuals of their human rights, their “freedom”, as George W. Bush so often stresses, quite hypocritically.

An important word here is ‘human’, as we are referring to people with feelings and needs and a natural instinct to pursue love and happiness in their lives. Let us treat them accordingly.

I feel homosexual marriages are a great opportunity for children with no parents to be adopted. However, some people argue that it is a bad environment for children to grow up in, as there is no father or mother figure. What is the divorce rate in the U.S.? 50 per cent, and it is alleged that some states do not report divorces to the National Center for Health Statistics. I would say a stable and loving household with two parents is a good environment in which to grow up, wouldn’t you?

Figures did not seem to be available for the U.S., but perhaps this could be used as a reflection of the circumstances present in most countries: In Denmark, who legalised same-sex marriage in 1995, the rate of divorce between homosexuals is 17 per cent as opposed to 46 per cent for heterosexuals.

Some people argue that their child or children will be bullied in school. Well, we should eradicate the government-induced and media-perpetuated taboo on homosexuality and teach children that it is okay, a natural process in life, not something to fear and approach with insecurity.

I would argue that they might be bullied by adults alike. We should teach them in the same way as the children.

Perhaps we need to consider this from a homosexual’s point of view, in order to understand their situation adequately. How would you feel if your chosen or fated way of life was restricted and portrayed as illegitimate and wrong by your government and the opposing majority? Or, transversely, if you were forced to be homosexual?

A recent report by the Government Accountability Office states that $US200 million was spent over the last decade to replace the positions which were held by some 9,500 people who were kicked out of the service for being homosexual. When I read this, I found myself asking: was it really worth it?

In an article written by Michael Foust, Peter LaBarbera, executive director of the Illinois Family Institute, said, in relation to the aforementioned episode of The Simpsons, that it is inappropriate to introduce an adult topic into a cartoon. I think this person is assuming that all cartoons are aimed primarily at children, which The Simpsons obviously is not; and it would not be the first time the producers have dealt with adult issues, including homosexuality, an episode for which they won an Emmy award.

He also said “. . . They’re teaching the acceptance of homosexuality to toddlers.” I fail to see the point or understand any possible negative connotation of this remark. And why should the producers of The Simpsons not express their views, or reflect the views and circumstances of society? Is America not ‘Land of the Free’?

Also: “. . . Homosexuality is being promoted and celebrated and treated as if it’s no big deal.” Diversity, open-mindedness and personal freedom are a ‘big deal’ now? Have I missed something?

I feel it is opinions such as these that create and encourage negativity towards homosexuality. Why anyone would wish to denounce the growth of humanity, our culture, and denounce that which is human is something I do not comprehend. A step forward is never three steps backward, and giving homosexuals the rights they deserve is a positive move for all governments concerned.